The judge presiding over the Brianna Ghey trial cautions against making threats towards the families of the murderers.

In her written judgment, Mrs Justice Yip emphasizes the importance of avoiding “vitriol or malice” and urges people to refrain from directing such actions towards the families of the teenage killers. The judge overseeing the Brianna Ghey trial warns that doing so would disregard the explicit wishes of the victim’s grieving mother. Mrs Justice Yip announces her decision to lift the reporting restrictions on the teenagers’ names during their sentencing on 2 February, citing a “strong public interest in full and unrestricted reporting” due to the exceptional nature of the case. The local council informs Yip that the family of the female defendant has already received death threats. Brianna was fatally stabbed 28 times with a hunting knife in Culcheth, a village near Warrington, Cheshire, on 11 February. Yip’s written judgment urges those responsible for the threats to reflect on their role in society, considering that their dark thoughts and hateful messages materialized into real-life actions. While the defendants could have been named upon turning 18, the judge believes that continuing the court order granting anonymity until then would disproportionately restrict press freedom. Yip acknowledges that the defendants and their families have been identified online, suggesting their identities are already known within their local communities. She acknowledges the distress and anguish the defendants’ families will face upon their identities being revealed, considering the threats and harassment they have already endured. However, she emphasizes that the purpose of the restrictions is not solely to protect the families of convicted defendants. Yip asserts that the distress caused by publication would not differ significantly if the defendants reached their majority in 2025. She believes that the risk of further threats and harassment will persist regardless of whether the defendants are named now or in the future. Yip commends Esther Ghey, Brianna’s mother, for her remarkable strength and compassion when she requested empathy and understanding towards the killers’ parents outside the courtroom after the verdict. The judge reminds individuals that those who have witnessed the defendants’ parents in court during the trial would recognize their suffering. She urges individuals tempted to direct vitriol or malice towards the defendants’ families to consider that they would be acting against Brianna’s bereaved mother’s explicit wishes. Throughout the trial, the killers’ parents were present in court, while Brianna’s family observed from the public gallery upstairs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *